Distinguish flank wear, crater wear, notching, built-up edge and fracture.
Identify the damage before changing cutting data. Similar symptoms can have different causes; a photograph is evidence to investigate, not a complete diagnosis.
Locate the wear
Flank wear develops on the clearance face; crater wear is on the rake face. A notch is localized around the depth-of-cut line. Built-up edge is work material adhering to the cutting edge and must not be mistaken for missing carbide. Inspect safely with the machine stopped and secured according to procedure.
Check the process as well as the insert
Sudden chipping or fracture calls for checks of clamping, seat cleanliness, screw condition, overhang, interrupted engagement and trapped chips. Review grade, geometry and cutting data against the actual material and toolmaker guidance. Reducing every parameter together can hide the cause or introduce rubbing.
Make the comparison repeatable
Use the same camera angle and lighting. Record tool reference, edge number, cutting minutes, accepted parts, operation and fluid conditions. Change one approved factor at a time; compare wear at equal cutting exposure, not merely after equal calendar time.
Define the stopping criterion
Use the workshop quality plan and toolmaker limits. Dimensional drift, unacceptable finish, cracking or an unstable edge require assessment before further production. There is no universal replacement threshold for every insert and component. Keep the rejected edge and its record for diagnosis.